Netac Z Slim review: Too slow and too expensive for what it offers

One-minute review

The Netac Z Slim is a portable solid state drive that is , compact, reasonably solid, affordable but slow.

It has a full aluminum case which can scratch easily but doesn’t feel tacky given its black color and the lack of any garish features. The Z Slim comes with the strict minimum when it comes to accessories: just USB cable, an adapter and a pouch and there is no bundled software. There’s an LED as well and is available in capacities ranging from 250GB to 2TB. Just bear in mind that it doesn’t carry any IP or MIL-STD ratings; so don’t drop it in a glass of water to impress your colleagues, this is not a water resistant device. It still feels reasonably solid but be aware of these limitations (even if it includes a three-year ).

Netac claims that the drive should reach read/write speeds of up to 500 MBps which is slow by today’s standards. That’s because the company chose to use SATA parts rather than the more common and faster NVMe; I cannot fathom; it looks – to me at least – as a way to drive the bill of material to as low as possible. But basement, this one isn’t.

The Z Slim ranks amongst the most expensive “slow” (i.e. SATA based) external SSDs on the market right now. To make things worse, there’s even a handful of portable SSD that offer twice the speed of the Z Slim with a lower tag.

Netac Z Slim portable SSD outside during our testing

(Image credit: Netac)

Netac Z Slim: and availability

In a fiercely competitive category, the Z Slim faces some tough competition; with little to differentiate between the , it’s very often down to price and at the time of writing, that’s a contest that the Z Slim has lost and one that ultimately prevents it from entering our best portable SSD buying

Netac Z Slim portable SSD outside during our testing phase

(Image credit: Netac Z Slim)

Netac Z Slim: Benchmark

Given what I knew about the Z Slim, the test results are in no way surprising. Netac says that it will reach 550 MBps on read and write and we got close to those numbers during our synthetic . That number goes way down in real life tests, just under 400 MBps. The drive didn’t warm up even under load. 

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Row 0 – Cell 0 Read (MBps) Write (MBps)
AJA 501 461
CrystalDiskMark 588 508
ATTO 533 481
AS SSD 510 465
Real Life 394 394

Netac Z Slim: Specs

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Row 0 – Cell 0 Row 0 – Cell 1
Capacities available 250GB, 500GB, 1TB, 2TB
Size 100 x 29 x 9mm
Weight 30g
Enclosure material ABS plastic
Connector USB-C
Technology USB 3.2 Gen 2
Warranty (in years) 3
Rated R/W speeds (MBps) 550/550
Software bundle No
Accessories Sleeve, USB-A to USB-C cable and a USB-C adapter

Base of the Netac Z Slim showing the charging port during our tests

(Image credit: Netac)

Should I buy the Netac Z Slim?

Netac Z Slim alternatives

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Row 0 – Cell 0 SSK Silicon Power PC60 Lexar SL200
1TB 0.96TB 1TB
Price $59.99 $49.99 $44.88
Speed USB 3.2 Gen 2 USB 3.2 Gen 2 USB 3.2 Gen 2
IP rated no no no
Warranty (yrs) 3 3 3

The SSK is the fastest of the affordable alternatives with a rated read/write speed of 1050/1000 MBps. It has a useful carabiner and is a tad thicker than the Z Slim.

The Silicon Power PC60 is bland, unassuming and average in everything except its price. It is an entry-level, affordable and capable device that is far, far cheaper than the competition.

The Lexar SL2000 portable SSD is the cheapest 1TB portable SSD right now. Its chassis is mainly plastic and it is bulkier than the Z Slim but that shouldn’t bother bargain hunters.

How I tested the Netac Z Slim

After having formatted the Z Slim to exFAT, I test it the same way I test other storage components (external HDD, microSD cards etc). I use the latest versions of CrystalDiskMark, Atto, AS SSD and AJA benchmarks, noting the best scores achieved in each. They are all free and can be downloaded by . I also transferred a folder of random files, roughly 10GB in size, to get a rough idea of real life performance. 

Source link